I’d been wanting to try one of Sugar & Plumm’s milkshakes for a while but didn’t know which one to choose. I asked which was their most popular, and they replied with the Hot Chocolate and Grasshopper shakes. I chose the Hot Chocolate! The employee recommended swapping the chocolate ice cream for vanilla so you can really taste the hot chocolate mix. I decided I should trust that opinion and swapped the ice cream. I’m glad I did because she was right. Of course, it reminded me of the frozen hot chocolate at Serendipity, but in this shake, I could really taste the hot cocoa and the top was covered with marshmallows. What I love as well about Sugar & Plumm is that their ice cream is homemade and that really makes a difference. The shake was so creamy and smooth. Not too thick, not too runny. The days are finally getting hotter now, so compliment the heat with a cool Sugar & Plumm milkshake!